Last Thursday at the annual Owners' Meetings, Bud Selig met with his newly formed 14-man committee and acknowledged that
changes are coming to baseball in the very near future. Now what we don't know is what those changes are but according to Joe Torre and Mike Scioscia, two of the 14 members, the topics that were discussed were plentiful.
So what kind of changes might we see? Expansion of first round LDS playoff series to seven games? Fewer off days between playoff games? The elimination of the designated hitter? Expansion of instant replay? How about league expansion?
I'm all for each of the above suggestions. Obviously, they each have their own drawbacks and hurdles to jump for any of them to come to fruition. But at the same time, there are very good reasons to implement each of them.
Expanding the LDS to seven games means playing more games in November. But it also gives teams with the better records a better chance of advancing past the first round. Condensing the post-season schedule means the networks lose out on possible revenue, but the need for extra off days goes back to the why you don't want to expand the first round and be playing into November, where the weather becomes a bigger factor, especially on the east coast and in colder winter climates.
Eliminating the designated hitter would be a major obstacle with the players union as it could affect players careers. But is it really needed? Has the designated hitter really helped over the long haul?
The instant replay system is fine as it is and really shouldn't be tinkered with. It's enough that it's even in the game as it is.
Expanding the league is probably the longest of long shots here, and probably not even on the agenda for discussion with the committee, but for fun, let's play around with this idea.
I would be all for it for a number of reasons. By adding two more teams and realigning the leagues into four four-team divisions, you could eliminate the Wild Card, expand the LDS to seven games while cutting out off days in the post-season, and possibly even shorten the season back down to 154 games. I had given this some thought some months ago and think I might have come up with a realignment system that could work.
The National League could look like this:
West: Arizona, LA Dodgers, San Diego, San Francisco
Central: Chicago Cubs, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, St. Louis
South: Florida, Houston, Oklahoma City (Expansion Team 1), Tampa Bay
East: Atlanta, NY Mets, Philly, Washington
The American League could look like this:
West: LA Angels, Oakland, Portland (Expansion Team 2), Seattle
Central: Colorado, Kansas City, Minnesota, Texas
North: Chicago Sox, Cleveland, Detroit, Milwaukee
East: Baltimore, Boston, NY Yankees, Toronto
In this format, the divisions would keep most of the old rivalries intact. To make it work, Milwaukee would have to move back to the American League and Colorado and Tampa Bay would have to switch places so that they fit geographically in a suitable division. I don't think any of those franchises would be opposed to it.
As for the expansion teams, I came up with four viable cities/regions that could support a Major League team, and then eliminated two. Portland, Oregon is the largest city in the country without a team. They've been candidates in the past for expansion, as well as relocation, so it would only seem logical to add Portland. The next most populous city without a team is Sacramento, but I think it's still too close in proximity to the Bay Area. The Giants and A's would have a big problem with adding a team there. That leaves the last two cities/regions that I came up with being Oklahoma City and the Carolinas. I think Oklahoma City would be more receptive to having a Major League team than the Carolinas would, so they would get the nod here.
We really have no idea what's on the menu and what changes could be coming. The whole expansion thing by adding two teams is extremely far-fetched in that I highly doubt Selig or the owners would ever go for it, but I really like the idea of it for the reasons I mentioned above. It seems to me that some of the other ideas probably have a better chance of becoming a reality than league expansion, and if I had to put money down on what changes I think are coming, I'd put it down on either expanding the LDS to seven games or cutting back the number of off days during the playoffs. Or both.